Avoiding the Insights Graveyard: Three Keys to Using AI on Insights Without Making It Worse
Scott Thompson explains why insight reports keep improving while action lags, and shares three upstream keys that keep Medical Affairs insights out of the graveyard.
Medical Affairs teams are getting better at defining insights, combining data sources, and using AI to speed up analysis and reporting, yet many insights still end up in the insights graveyard: reviewed, reported, and never acted on. In a 2020 survey of Medical Affairs Professional Society (MAPS) members responsible for insights, 74% of respondents’ organizations had an established insight review and analysis process, but the most significant challenge respondents named was identifying real insights, linking them to action, and demonstrating their impact.
Scott Thompson (CEO, Acceleration Point) explains why insight reports keep improving while action still lags, and what Field Medical, insights, and Medical Strategy teams can change upstream of their insight-to-action meetings. The insights graveyard is where insights land when they are collected and reported but never used to inform a decision. Scott Thompson organizes the session around three keys: decisions, depth, and discipline. Key insight questions (KIQs) are the questions a Medical Affairs organization defines to direct what its collectors listen for, and Scott Thompson shows how a Microsoft Copilot notebook can use KIQs to coach MSLs through insight capture in the moment. The demo builds on the approach from his earlier webinar, Going Beyond the Prompt. If your insight reports are getting better but decisions are not changing, start with this session.
What You’ll Learn
- Insight programs drive more action when home office decision makers help set the insight strategy, rather than leaving it to collectors such as Field Medical, Medical Information, and medical education teams.
- Every member of an insights team should be able to finish Scott Thompson’s sentence: “We need to understand blank so that who can decide what.”
- Asking collectors to supply an observation, an insight, and a recommended action in every submission can stall collection. Teams doing this well ask for the observation, then work toward a documented conclusion through analysis. (Related: rethinking insight capture workflows)
- A three-level insight captures what an HCP does or believes, why the HCP does or believes it, and what might change it, so the third level comes from the source instead of being guessed in debrief meetings.
- Capturing level one as structured multiple-choice responses and levels two and three as free text improves consistency across collectors and gives AI a structure to work from.
- The confidence test holds insight data to the standard of being strong enough to share externally, and moving AI to the point of capture helps teams meet that standard without adding administrative burden.
FAQ
What is the insights graveyard in Medical Affairs?
The insights graveyard is where Medical Affairs insights end up when they are collected, reviewed, and reported but never used to inform a decision. Scott Thompson, CEO of Acceleration Point, describes the pattern as reports that improve while action stays missing: home office leaders say they do not get what they need to drive decisions, and Field Medical teams question why they should keep submitting insights when nothing happened.
What are the three keys to avoiding the insights graveyard?
Scott Thompson identifies three upstream keys. Decisions: involve the people who make decisions early and ask what they need to know to feel confident. Depth: capture what an HCP does or believes, why, and what might change it. Discipline: collect consistently enough, from the right people, that the data can support a conclusion.
What is a three-level insight?
A three-level insight is an insight structure with three questions. Level one records what an HCP does or believes. Level two records why the HCP does or believes it. Level three records what might change it, meaning what would cause the HCP to reconsider that decision or belief. Scott Thompson recommends capturing level one as multiple choice and levels two and three as free text.
How can AI improve medical insight capture?
Scott Thompson recommends moving AI earlier in the process, to the point of capture, rather than using it only to summarize data at the end. In the webinar, he demonstrates a Microsoft Copilot notebook loaded with a team’s KIQs and custom instructions that matches an MSL’s debrief to the relevant KIQs, suggests answers, and asks follow-up questions one at a time.
What is the confidence test for medical insights?
The confidence test asks whether insight data is strong enough that a Medical Affairs team would be willing to show it externally. Scott Thompson’s reasoning is that if the data does not meet that standard, internal teams have little reason to act on it. Volume alone does not pass the test; the data must come from the right people and specialties and show consistent answers.
About Our Speaker
Scott Thompson is CEO at Acceleration Point. Scott Thompson helped teach a Medical Affairs Professional Society (MAPS) master class and has led hands-on AI sessions for Medical Affairs leaders. Scott and his team have coached hundreds of MSLs on insights.
Connect with Scott on LinkedIn: linkedin.com/in/medical-excellence
Curious how this applies to your organization? Let’s talk.
About Acceleration Point Webinars
Acceleration Point webinars bring Medical Affairs and Field Medical leaders together to share practical insights, emerging strategies, and real-world perspectives on the challenges shaping the industry. Each session is designed to support the professionals driving scientific exchange, field medical excellence, and Medical Affairs transformation.
Explore More Resources
Discover more insights, case studies, and podcasts from our team.
Browse All Resources